As the cost of care at home continues to rise, families are facing increasingly difficult decisions about how best to support older relatives. But are we focusing too much on paying for care once it is needed, and not enough on helping people remain independent in the first place?
For many older people, remaining in their own home for as long as possible is hugely important. Familiar surroundings, independence and a sense of belonging all contribute to wellbeing and quality of life.
However, as people get older, they may begin to need additional help, and for many families, the cost of arranging that support can be daunting.
The cost of privately funded domiciliary care varies depending on location, the agency and the level of support required.
For a family paying £35 per hour, the costs quickly add up:
| Care required | Approximate annual cost |
|---|---|
| One hour every day | £12,775 |
| Two hours every day | £25,550 |
| Three hours every day | £38,325 |
| Four hours every day | £51,100 |
Figures are illustrative and based on 365 days of care at £35 per hour, excluding additional charges.
For someone requiring several visits each day, the annual cost can easily exceed £50,000.
But perhaps the bigger question is whether we are making the best possible use of the money families and public services spend on supporting older people at home.
The problem isn’t just what care costs. It’s how we use it.
There is another important issue that often gets overlooked.
Not everyone who needs help at home needs professional personal care.
Some older people require assistance with washing, dressing, toileting or other personal care tasks. Where these services are provided professionally, they must be delivered safely and, where required, by appropriately regulated providers.
But others may simply be struggling with everyday life.
Perhaps shopping has become difficult. Preparing meals feels like a chore. The house is harder to manage, or they are spending long periods alone without anyone to talk to.
These challenges can have a significant impact on wellbeing and independence, but they do not necessarily require a professional care worker.
And this is where we believe the conversation needs to change.
Rather than waiting until someone needs more intensive support, shouldn’t we be doing more to help them maintain their independence in the first place?
Prevention: the missing piece of the care puzzle
We hear a great deal about the pressures facing adult social care, the NHS and local authorities.
Yet comparatively little attention is given to the everyday support that might help prevent someone’s circumstances from deteriorating.
Loneliness, isolation, poor nutrition, difficulties managing household tasks and reduced confidence can all affect an older person’s ability to continue living independently.
Addressing these issues early may help people remain happier, healthier and more confident at home.
It may also reduce or delay the need for more intensive support in some circumstances.
This is not about replacing professional care with cheaper alternatives. It is about recognising that different needs require different solutions.
A person who needs help getting washed and dressed requires appropriate personal care.
A person who is lonely, needs help with shopping or would benefit from someone sharing an evening meal may need something quite different.
And many people will benefit from a combination of both.
Where Homeshare fits in
At Share and Care Homeshare, we have spent 20 years helping older people remain independent in their own homes through companionship and practical support.
Our Homeshare model brings together an older Householder who has a spare room with a carefully vetted and compatible Sharer looking for affordable accommodation.
In exchange for living in the home, the Sharer provides an agreed contribution of practical help and companionship, typically around ten hours of practical help and up to five hours of companionship each week.
This might include shopping, preparing meals, light household tasks, sharing conversation or simply providing a friendly presence in the home.
Sharers are not carers.
They do not provide personal care, manage medication or replace professional care services.
However, for someone who does not need personal care but would benefit from companionship and everyday practical help, Homeshare can offer an affordable and reassuring solution.
And where professional care is already in place, Homeshare can work alongside it, providing the companionship and practical support that time-pressured care visits may not be able to offer.
For many families, knowing that an older relative has regular company and practical help can also provide considerable peace of mind.
Could investing in prevention save money?
This is a question we believe deserves much greater attention.
If someone can remain independent at home for longer because they have companionship, practical help and regular social interaction, there may be benefits not only for their wellbeing but also for the wider health and social care system.
Could preventative services help delay the need for additional domiciliary care?
Could they reduce loneliness and isolation, support recovery following a hospital stay or help some older people remain at home for longer?
And could earlier intervention reduce some of the financial pressures facing families and public services?
At Share and Care, we are working to gather more information about the experiences of our Householders, Sharers and their families, including changes in wellbeing, confidence and independence over time.
We want to build a stronger evidence base to help local authorities, government and commissioners understand the potential contribution of Homeshare within a wider preventative approach to adult social care.
We need a different conversation about care
Professional care workers do an incredibly important job, often in challenging circumstances. They deserve fair pay, proper recognition and working conditions that reflect the responsibility they carry.
Care agencies also need sustainable funding to deliver safe, high-quality services.
But families deserve transparency about what they are paying for, and taxpayers deserve confidence that public money is being used effectively.
We should also be asking what would help older people stay independent, connected and confident in their own homes.
Sometimes that will mean professional care.
Sometimes it will mean practical help and companionship.
Often, it will mean both.
Looking ahead: putting prevention at the heart of adult social care
As the government continues to consider the future of adult social care, we believe prevention must become a much bigger part of the discussion.
The question should not simply be how we fund an ever-increasing demand for care, but also how we help people maintain their independence and wellbeing for as long as possible.
Homeshare is not the answer to every challenge facing adult social care. But it is one example of how a different approach can bring people together, make better use of existing housing and offer meaningful support without automatically turning to paid care services.
After 20 years of bringing Householders and Sharers together, we have seen how much difference companionship and everyday practical help can make.
Now we want to build the evidence to demonstrate that difference more widely.
Because a sustainable future for adult social care shouldn’t just be about paying for more care. It should also be about helping people need less intensive care, wherever that is safely possible.
Sources and further reading
- Homecare Association – Fee Rates for State-Funded Homecare in England, 2026/27
- Care Quality Commission – Regulated Activities: Personal Care
- Social Care Institute for Excellence – Prevention in Social Care
Leave a Reply